Philip J. Weiser*
“We are in danger of becoming prisoners of our own procedures in the administrative process.” Newton N. Minow, FCC Chair, 1961-63[1]
The institutional failings of the FCC have finally begun to attract attention. For years, the agency tolerated a level of mystery and secrecy over what proposals would be submitted for consideration, an extraordinary reliance on the ex parte process at the expense of the formal notice-and-comment procedure, and a limited degree of collegial discussion among the Commissioners and the public. Of late, however, concerns about how the agency operates have become more pronounced and Congress has finally taken an interest in the question of whether and how to reform the FCC’s institutional processes. To that end, both House Commerce Committee Chair Emeritus John Dingell and Senate Commerce Committee Chair Jay Rockefeller have expressed serious concerns about how the agency operates,[2] the House Commerce Committee majority released a report citing serious failings in the operations of the agency,[3] and law professor Lawrence Lessig has called for its abolition.[4]
In response to the Congressional interest in institutional reform, the soon-to-be former Chairman Kevin Martin has disclaimed the need for any legislative action, has adjusted some of the FCC’s operating procedures, and, in the main, has defended the agency on the ground that his tactics are similar to those of his predecessors.[5] Whether or not Martin’s management style is different from past agency Chairs, the great weight of opinion is that the FCC has always operated in a suboptimal fashion and is in dire need of institutional reform. As former Commissioner Glen Robinson noted over forty years ago: “[f]ew agencies of Government have been so doggedly pursued by critics as the FCC.”[6] Former Chairman Reed Hundt added his own damning observation: that the agency suffers from a perennial “reputation for agency capture by special interests, mind-boggling delay, internal strife, lack of competence, and a dreadful record on judicial review.”[7] In short, the question is not whether to reform how the agency operates, but how to do so.
As new leadership moves to take the reigns at the FCC, it is an opportune moment to re-evaluate the agency’s institutional processes. In confronting the challenges facing the agency, the new leadership should not make the mistake of focusing solely on the substantive issues begging for attention-spectrum policy reform, network neutrality, and universal service policy to name a few. Rather, it should also take stock of its institutional processes, as they fundamentally shape the ability of the agency to be an effective regulator in the public interest.[8] In short, the agency’s current lack of data-driven decision-making and emphasis on political dealing hinders the thoughtfulness of its analysis, limits its ability to address issues effectively, and invites a cynical attitude toward government.[9] Unfortunately, legal scholars have not done their part to address the institutional failings of the FCC (and other administrative agencies, for that matter), glossing over the importance of institutional processes in favor of substantive policy analysis and generally focusing on the purely legal issues of administrative law as opposed to the actual operations of administrative agencies.[10]
This Article proceeds in five parts. Part I briefly describes the longstanding criticisms of how the FCC operates, highlighting a few recent episodes that have drawn attention to the need for institutional reform. Part II discusses the opportunity for the FCC to adopt a new institutional strategy for telecommunications policymaking, emphasizing the importance of strategic agenda setting and transparency. Part III explains how the agency can use its policymaking tools-rulemaking, adjudication, and merger review-more effectively. Part IV underscores the opportunity for the agency to upgrade its collection and dissemination of data as well as its involvement of the public in its decision-making processes. Part V offers a short conclusion.
* Professor of Law and Telecommunications, University of Colorado at Boulder. Thanks to the Ford Foundation for a grant to support this research and to Dan McCormick on first rate research assistance as well as to Mark Cooper, Pierre de Vries, Kyle Dixon, Ray Gifford, Dale Hatfield, Mike Marcus, Jonathan Nuechterlein, Adam Peters, Jonathan Sallet, Cathy Sharkey, Jim Speta, and Joe Waz for valuable comments and encouragement.
[1] Newton Minow, Suggestions for Improvement of the Administrative Process, 15 Admin. L. Rev. 146, 153 (1963).
[2] Letter from John D. Dingell, Chairman, House Comm. on Energy and Commerce, to Kevin J. Martin, Chairman, Fed. Commc’ns Comm. (Dec. 3, 2007), available at http://energycommerce.house.gov/Press_110/110-ltr.120307.FCC.Martin.transparency.pdf (“Given several events and proceedings over the past year, I am rapidly losing confidence that the Commission has been conducting its affairs in an appropriate manner.”); Ted Hearn, Watching the Martin Watch, MultichannelNews, Jan. 21, 2008, http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6524092.html (calling on the Senate to evaluate the “structure of the agency, its mission, the terms of the commissioners, and how to make the agency a better regulator, advocate for consumers, and a better resource for Congress”).
[3] Committee on Energy and Commerce Majority Staff Report, Deception and Distrust: The Federal Communications Commission Under Chairman Kevin J.Martin (December 2008), http://energycommerce.house.gov/images/stories/Documents/PDF/Newsroom/fcc%20majority%20staff%20report%20081209.pdf [hereinafter, Deception and Distrust].
[4] Lawrence Lessig, Reboot the FCC, Newsweek.com, December 23, 2003, http://www.newsweek.com/id/176809.
[5] John Eggerton, Martin: FCC Doesn’t Need Major Reform, Broadcasting & Cable, Jan. 15, 2008, http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/CA6522942.html (quoting Martin as stating that “[i]n general, our processes aren’t any different than they were under previous chairmen both Republican and Democrat.”). Some longtime agency observers essentially second Martin’s judgment, noting that “[t]he FCC needs to reform and it has needed to for 25 years. . .Too much is done behind closed doors secretly and it has been that way through Democratic and Republican leadership.” Cecilia Kang, FCC Chair Abused Power, House Probe Finds, Washington Post, December 12, 2008, at D1, http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/12/09/AR2008120903132_pf.html (quoting Consumer Union’s Gene Kimmelman).
[6] Glen O. Robinson, Radio Spectrum Regulation: The Administrative Process and the Problems of Institutional Reform, 53 Minn. L. Rev. 1179, 1239 (1969).
[7] Reed E. Hundt & Gregory L. Rosston, Communications Policy for 2006 and Beyond, 58 Fed. Comm. L.J. 1, 31 (2006).
[8] In explaining his commitment to a serious evaluation of the Federal Trade Commission’s institutional processes (as part of an “FTC at 100” study), Chairman Bill Kovacic explained that “[t]he quality of institutional design, institutional infrastructure, and institutional process has a great deal to do with determining the quality of substantive outcomes. The same energy that’s dedicated to asking what’s the right doctrine or what’s the right conceptual framework has to be applied to questions concerning optimal institutional design and operational arrangements.” Interview with William E. Kovacic, Chairman, Federal Trade Commission, Antitrust Source 1 (August 2008), http://www.ftc.gov/speeches/kovacic/2008kovacicintrvwc.pdf.
[9] Jim Puzzanghera, Criticism of the FCC’s Chairman is Widely Aired, L.A. Times, Dec. 10, 2007, at C1 (“Critics have complained that important issues - such as the 2009 transition to digital television and reforming a fund that subsidizes phone and Internet service for low-income and rural residents - are taking a back seat to bickering.”). The often cavalier attitude toward regulation was described and bemoaned by Judge Posner as follows:
There has I think been a tendency of recent Administrations, both Republican and Democratic but especially the former, not to take regulation very seriously. This tendency expresses itself in deep cuts in staff and in the appointment of regulatory administrators who are either political hacks or are ideologically opposed to regulation. (I have long thought it troublesome that Alan Greenspan was a follower of Ayn Rand.) This would be fine if zero regulation were the social desideratum, but it is not. The correct approach is to carve down regulation to the optimal level but then finance and staff and enforce the remaining regulatory duties competently and in good faith. Judging by the number of scandals in recent years involving the regulation of health, safety, and the environment, this is not being done.
Richard Posner, Re-Regulate Financial Markets?, The Becker-Posner Blog, Apr. 28, 2008, http://www.becker-posner-blog.com/archives/2008/04/reregulate_fina.html.
[10] Unfortunately, the complaint of law professor and former FCC Commissioner Nick Johnson lodged over a quarter century ago still holds: “[r]ather than seeking methods for improving the administrative process to avoid unsound, unfair, and arbitrary decisions, scholars have focused almost exclusively on the role of courts in supervising and reviewing agency action.” Nicholas Johnson, The Second Half of Jurisprudence: The Study of Administrative Decisionmaking, 23 Stan. L. Rev. 173, 173 (1970) (reviewing Kenneth Culp Davis, Discretionary Justice: A Preliminary Inquiry (1969)) [hereinafter, Administrative Decisionmaking].
Comments
Excellent post, went ahead
Excellent post, went ahead and bookmarked your site. I can’t wait to read more from you. gclub
This is an excellent post I
This is an excellent post I seen thanks to share it. It is really what I wanted to see hope in future you will continue for sharing such a excellent post. คาสิโนออนไลน์
Hello Guys!
I had been try it before , Harga Blackberry Put one chicken leg in the enginee, but I did contrl the cooking time so it’s not hot enough alos fall down in a small hole in my car enginee. But I feel it’s intresting. My experience, maybe put one steel plate and binding it. Maybe suitable for the long time driving! Expecialy in a rough road??
Online Writing
GREAT BLOG! You are one of the best writers I’ve seen in a long long time. I hope you keep writing because people like you inspire me!
Wow! This can be one
Wow! This can be one particular of the most helpful blogs We have ever arrive across on this subject. Actually Fantastic. I’m also an expert in this topic therefore I can understand your effort Buy Fresh Fruit Gift Baskets and Organic Gift Baskets from the USA’s reputable gift basket company.
App Developer
This is a great blog,I like this post it is very good and informative. I am sure that this post will be very much helpful for people.
iPhone App Development
That’s a wonderful
That’s a wonderful information and it will be very helpful in many fields. Thanks for sharing. online video production
this information is very much
this information is very much impressive.. I am glad to read this article. Free Directory
Great Post :
Great job here. I really enjoyed what you had to say. Keep going because you definitely bring a new voice to this subject. Not many people would say what you’ve said and still make it interesting. Well, at least I’m interested. Cant wait to see more of this from you.
TNS
Great stuff from you, man. I’ve read your stuff before and you’re just too awesome. I love what you’ve got here, love what you’re saying and the way you say it. You make it entertaining and you still manage to keep it smart.
TNS
Hello there! This blog post couldn’t be written any better! Looking through this post reminds me of my previous roommate! He constantly kept talking about this. I most certainly will send this article to him. Fairly certain he’s going to have a great read. Many thanks for sharing!
TNS
Truly remarkable labor with the blog. I do like your inflexible service and will wait for more post from you as your post gave me gratification and some help to do the same work right here. Thanks a lot!
check my site
The word capital itself has a very diverse meanings to many people. People will put forward the case that can describe the meaning of the term that you ask.
Meetings are very important
Meetings are very important if we are ATACADO DE ROUPAS
Well, that didn’t take very
Well, that didn’t take very long. Media suplementos importados and oxyelite pro preço
This layout is so stellar.
This layout is so stellar. How did you manage to make a blog that’s as smart as it is sleek? I mean, its like an Aston Martin —smart and sexy at the same time. hydra fund 2
Very efficiently written
Very efficiently written information. It will be beneficial to anybody who utilizes it, including me. Keep up the good work. For sure i will check out more posts. This site seems to get a good amount of visitors. hydra fund 2
hi
That is very interesting Smile I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this. This is exactly what I was looking for. Thanks for sharing this great article..
loans with bad credit
The long battery life is the topping the ice which will surely attract more customers and hence will help our partners sell more.
hello
Your article is both informative and interesting. You’ve made your points clear and I agree on most of them. Your content has given me reason to think and this is my favorite kind of material. nutrition topics from BestCustomWriting.com
Easily, the article is
Easily, the article is actually the best topic on this registry related issue. I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantasti c lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates. Promote Me Pro Review | macrobot marketer Review | Covert store builder Review
hi
Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work!
Good blog,thanks for your
Good blog,thanks for your sharing so great article.This is a regular article.hope you can keep writing more good aritcleThere are so many comments here that are really interesting and useful to me thanks for sharing a link especially for sharing this blog.
hi
I just got to this amazing site not long ago. I was actually captured with the piece of resources you have got here. Big thumbs up for making such wonderful blog page!
I recently came across your
I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading 60 second binary options
Definitely wonderful article.
Definitely wonderful article. The article touches many urgent issues of our minds. It is impossible to be uninvolved to these problems. This post gives good ideas and concepts. I really enjoyed simply reading. binary options scalper
Part of the Balearic
Part of the Balearic archipelago which also has the islands of Minorca and Ibiza among its components, yacht charter Mallorca is by far the largest and the most popular, because of its fine weather, the beaches and recently, the infrastructure. put option
I will ensure that I bookmark
I will ensure that I bookmark your blog and will come back in TAROT
Thanks for your researched
Thanks for your researched posting! I actually enjoyed reading it, you will be a great author.I will ensure that I bookmark your blog and will come back in the foreseeable future.
buy youtube views
We introduce ourselves as
We introduce ourselves as Indian handicrafts, manufacturers & exporters of Indianhandicrafts. Handicrafts from India has been recognized worldwide as a symbol of art that enriches the beauty and the glory naturally. We are leading Importers of Indian Handicrafts, Jewellery, Clothes, Cushion Covers, Bedcovers, Upholstery Fabric, Carpets, Chemicals and many other Handicrafts made of Brass and wood. Our new range of products include Plywood (commercial) and Leather products.
Nice article, thanks for
I want you to thank for your time of this wonderful read Restposten Grosshandel Kontakte I definately enjoy every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff of your blog a must read blog!!!! Sonderposten Grosshandel Kontakte
I think it will be a great
I think it will be a great use of new ideas and informations. Thank you for sharing it with us.
1st, we require enough
1st, we require enough electricity. We should be stress-free along with at tranquility. The desire emanates from deep in a woman’s heart. It’s that will craving to plug and that will longing to talk about love along with passion. womenhealthblog
couldn’t make a decision if
couldn’t make a decision if this specific palate can be anti-seasonal (Easter hues in the heart of October) as well as playing off of the impending frosty white winter months. Either means, I’m ecstatic to separate the, “no bright pants immediately after labor day” junk. stylishjewelrywholesale
You’re seriously gonna love
You’re seriously gonna love these kind of pants. Nevertheless, as maybe you have guessed that they aren’t the most cost effective item on the globe. At $268 you’ll experience a hand techinque, but after you slip these kind of suckers in you’re gonna ignore the price and feel as if a trillion bucks. menandwomenwatches
I am the identical way with
I am the identical way with regards to Portugal! It’s a real magical place–particularly your Algarve. Scott along with I dream of the day you can own if you want a home there…we 1st visited throughout 2006, and I’m stoked I’ll be returning to college next May possibly finally! cabinsinontario
itsolexpert
I am very glad to find this post. itsolexpert
Thank you for sharing
Excellent read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research with this topic. And he actually bought me lunch because I ran across it for him. I really should thanks for the free lunch I obtained. Macrobot Marketer | Promote Me Pro
business valuation in Denver
Oh! Amazing and really rich content and very useful information. I got it my solution from over here. I highly recommend his/her workings with the useful informative information. Thanks a lot……….. business valuation in Denver
film streaming
MyMovies è lieta di presentare il primo portale italiano legale per film streaming, il sito in questione è italian streaming e secondo noi è il massimo in italia per la visione di film in streaming
I am sure this post has
I am sure this post has helped me save many hours of browsing other similar posts just to find what I was looking for. Linda W
I love this idea, it moves
I love this idea, it moves away from the traditional/old mantra ‘give aid to people in poverty’ to ‘help empower people to be in control of their own future keep it up!!
Most of the time I don’t make
Most of the time I don’t make comments on websites, but I’d like to say that this article really forced me to do so. Really nice post how to get free rp
Also, in his post you have
Also, in his post you have given a chance to listen about US Military. I really appreciate your work. Thanks for sharing it.
Yes, great US Military force.
Yes, great US Military force. Also, in his post you have given a chance to listen about US Military. I really appreciate your work. Thanks for sharing it.
Reply to comment | Reforming the FCC
I really like what you guys tend to be up too. This type of clever work and reporting! Keep up the awesome works guys I’ve included you guys to my own blogroll.
Most of the time I don’t make
Most of the time I don’t make comments on websites, but I’d like to say that this article really forced me to do so. Really nice post buy youtube views
Good blog,thanks for your
Good blog,thanks for your sharing so great article.This is a regular article.hope you can keep writing more good aritcleThere are so many comments here that are really interesting and useful to me thanks for sharing a link especially for sharing this blog
There has I think been a
There has I think been a tendency of recent Administrations, both Republican and Democratic but especially the former, not to take regulation very seriously.
What a good blog you have
What a good blog you have here. Please update it more often. This topics is my interest. Thank you… Kim Kardashian video
Post new comment